AI Learning Hub › Learn AI › Self-Paced Courses › Gemini Notebook: Working with Sources You Choose › Legal Research Extension: Research First, Then Build the Notebook
Optional extension
Legal Research Extension: Research First, Then Build the Notebook
An optional exercise for legal researchers: identify the authorities in Westlaw, check what later courts did with them, retrieve public copies from the courts, and only then build a notebook from what you found.
Every other exercise in this course starts with a source set already in front of you. This one does not — you build it.
You will take an unsettled question of federal law, find the authorities yourself, work out which are actually operative, retrieve public copies from the courts, and only then open a notebook. By the end you will have run the sequence a practicing lawyer runs, and you will be able to say which parts a notebook helped with and which parts it could not touch.
The order is the lesson: research first, notebook second, then back to the citator.
Before you begin. This is optional and sits outside the nine modules. It assumes you have worked through Follow the Citation and Know What Kind of Source You Are Citing, and that you have had a basic introduction to case searching and KeyCite in Westlaw. Allow a little longer if Westlaw or KeyCite is new to you.
On materials: use Westlaw to identify and validate the authorities, then obtain public copies from official sources before adding anything to Gemini Notebook. No case files are supplied with this exercise. Assembling the set is the point.
The research question
When can accessing publicly available website data after a website owner objects constitute access “without authorization” under the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act, particularly in the Ninth Circuit?
Keep it narrow. Scraping touches contract, copyright, trespass to chattels and privacy law, and all of that is outside this question. You are asking about one statutory phrase in one circuit.
Fair warning: this question is not settled. If your research produces a clean rule, look harder.
Step 1 — Find the statute
Pull up 18 U.S.C. § 1030 in Westlaw. Read subsection (a), then the definitions in subsection (e).
Two phrases carry the weight in this area: without authorization and exceeds authorized access. Before going further, answer one question from the statute alone.
Which phrase does the statute define — “without authorization,” “exceeds authorized access,” or both?
Only one of them is defined, in § 1030(e). The other appears throughout subsection (a) and is left to the courts.
That asymmetry is not a drafting curiosity. It is where the litigation comes from, and it explains why a Supreme Court decision construing one phrase does not automatically settle the meaning of the other. Hold onto this when you reach Step 7.
Step 2 — Search for controlling authority
Set your jurisdiction before you type the query. A search scoped to state courts will return nothing for a federal question, and zero results look exactly like a finding. Set the scope to federal cases, confirm it is showing, and only then run the search.
A workable starting query:
"without authorization" /p ("publicly accessible" OR "publicly available" OR scrap!)
Run it in federal cases. Once you see what comes back, experiment with narrowing by date; the Supreme Court decided the leading CFAA case in June 2021, which makes a natural cut-off to test.
Two practical notes. If a quoted phrase behaves unexpectedly, simplify the query and confirm the active content scope before concluding there are no results — searching a section number such as 1030 is often steadier than a quoted statute name. And expect district court decisions to dominate the results; ask which are binding in the Ninth Circuit and which are only persuasive.
Read enough to form a view. You are looking for a small set — roughly three to five primary authorities plus the statute — that genuinely help answer the question.
Step 3 — Check which opinion is operative
Somewhere in your results you will likely meet a case with two Ninth Circuit opinions, in the same litigation, between the same parties:
938 F.3d 985 (9th Cir. 2019) 31 F.4th 1180 (9th Cir. 2022)
Both discuss the CFAA and public website data at length. A full-text search will return either one.
Which should you rely on as the operative Ninth Circuit decision, and how can you tell?
The newer citation is not automatically the right one, and a later date is not a reason. Open the case history in Westlaw and read what happened between the two.
Once you have checked the history
The Supreme Court granted certiorari, vacated the earlier judgment, and sent the case back for reconsideration. The 2022 opinion is the decision on remand, and it is the one to rely on.
Two terms worth having:
- Vacated — a court has set aside the earlier judgment. Not criticized, not distinguished: deprived of effect. You can read a vacated opinion for its reasoning, but it is not authority.
- Subsequent history — the later proceedings affecting a decision: appeals, reversals, vacaturs, remands.
Nothing in the text of the earlier opinion tells you any of this. It reads exactly as authoritative as it did the day it was filed. You learn it from a citator, which is the whole point of this step.
Whatever you conclude, write down how you confirmed it. “It was more recent” is not a method.
Step 4 — Check treatment
Run KeyCite on every authority you are considering, and separate three questions.
- Did anything happen to this decision itself?
- Negative direct history — reversed, vacated, superseded. The most serious, and the first thing to look at.
- What have other courts done with it?
- Citing references. A case can collect a warning flag because later courts distinguished it on facts, which tells you about the edges of its reasoning rather than its validity.
- Does any of that touch my proposition?
- The question people skip, and usually the one that decides whether you can still cite the case.
You may well find an authority in this area carrying a negative flag. Before you drop it, ask yourself:
If a case has negative treatment, does that mean every proposition in it is unusable?
No. Treatment can affect only part of a decision. A case may be overruled in part on a question — a point about sentencing or restitution, say — that has nothing to do with why you want to cite it, while the holding you need remains untouched and is still being applied.
Open the treating decision and find out what was actually overruled, narrowed or criticized. Then ask whether it reaches your proposition.
“Has a red flag” is not a research conclusion. “Overruled in part, on a different issue, and the proposition I am relying on was applied by the circuit recently” is.
Legal authority changes over time. Use a current citator whenever the status of an authority matters; nothing on this page is a substitute for checking it yourself on the day.
Step 5 — Retrieve public copies
For every authority you have decided to use: record the citation from Westlaw, find the official public version, confirm it is the same decision, save it, and record the URL.
- Supreme Court opinions
- supremecourt.gov (opens in a new tab)
- Ninth Circuit opinions
- ca9.uscourts.gov (opens in a new tab)
- Federal statutes
- uscode.house.gov (opens in a new tab) or govinfo.gov (opens in a new tab)
Use another reputable public source only where an official one is not reasonably available, and record which you used.
Give every file a descriptive name. An uploaded file takes its filename as its source title in the notebook, so case-name-court-year.pdf tells you what a citation points at and document.pdf does not. This is the Module 2 lesson arriving somewhere it has real consequences.
One format note: statutes are often published both as a print-layout PDF and as HTML. The PDF reproduces a two-column printed page, which breaks words across lines with hyphens, so an exact-phrase search inside your notebook can miss matches. Where an official text-native HTML version exists, prefer it.
Your research record
Fill this in before you open Gemini Notebook. It is the bridge between the two halves of the exercise, and it is what you keep afterwards.
| Authority | Citation | Court / year | Proposition I may use it for | Treatment checked? | Public source URL | | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
Aim for three to five primary authorities plus the statute. If your research identified a Supreme Court decision, include it, along with the Ninth Circuit authority you think controls. Your set does not have to match anyone else's — it has to be defensible, and you have to be able to say why each item is in it.
Step 6 — Build your Notebook source set
Now, and only now, open Gemini Notebook. Create a fresh notebook, upload the public copies you retrieved, and open the Sources panel before you ask anything.
Check three things: that every filename is descriptive enough to be useful in a citation, that the source count matches what you intended to upload, and that nothing unexpected is in the list.
Upload only the public copies. The material you worked with inside Westlaw — its presentation of the opinions, its editorial notes, its citator output — stays in Westlaw, where you used it.
Step 7 — Compare the authorities
Prompt to try
Using only the sources in this notebook, compare how the courts treat access "without authorization." Identify the factual and legal distinctions that appear to matter. For each major proposition, identify the supporting authority.
Then push on the answer. Distinctions worth testing against what you actually read:
- Was authorization ever required in the first place, or was the material open to anyone?
- Who gave permission, and who withdrew it? Those can be different parties.
- Was there an express revocation, or only a term of use?
- Whose credentials were used?
- Is the court construing without authorization or exceeds authorized access?
- What kind of holding is it? A preliminary-injunction ruling on serious questions going to the merits is not the same as a conviction affirmed on appeal, and the two should not be stacked.
If the notebook hands you a tidy rule, your job is to find the case that does not fit it.
The question the Supreme Court did not answer
Now look specifically at the Supreme Court authority in your set.
Prompt to try
Find the Supreme Court authority in this notebook and read the footnote where the Court discusses what it is not deciding about authorization. What issue does the Court leave unresolved?
Hint: look at footnote 8.
Then open the footnote in the opinion itself and read it. Having found it, work out why it matters for the Ninth Circuit cases you are comparing: if the question the Court reserved were answered one way, what happens to the result in each of your cases? If it were answered the other way?
Step 8 — Follow the citations
Pick three important claims from the notebook's analysis and check each one against the opinion behind it. This is the method from Follow the Citation, applied where the stakes are higher.
| Notebook claim | Citation | Underlying authority | Supporting passage | Exact wording, proposition, or both? | | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
A paraphrase that drifts slightly can turn a holding into dictum, a narrow rule into a broad one, or a preliminary finding into a settled one. If you intend to quote a court, quote from the opinion.
Step 9 — Return to the citator
Two questions close the exercise.
Which parts of your analysis depend on whether these authorities are still current or have later treatment?
What would you need to recheck before relying on this analysis professionally?
“Verify everything” is not an answer. A useful one names the proposition, the authority carrying it, and the thing that could undermine it. Work through the specific checks: subsequent history, negative treatment, citing references, newer controlling authority, current precedential status.
Notice what you are not doing. You are not asking the notebook whether its own analysis is still good law. It holds your documents and nothing else, and it does not know what was decided last month.
Your research and verification record
The deliverable, and it should be short.
- Research record — your authority table from before Step 6.
- Notebook source set — the public sources you selected, with URLs.
- Verification record — your three claim-to-passage checks.
- Reflection — a paragraph on each of two questions: what did Westlaw or the citator tell you that the notebook could not, and what did the notebook make easier once the authority set was established?
Why this workflow matters
The two tools are not competing, and this exercise is not a contest between them.
Legal research does something a notebook cannot: it finds the authorities, tells you which are binding, and tells you what has happened to them since. None of that is in the text of an opinion — it lives in the apparatus around it. A notebook, in turn, is good at something research platforms are clumsy at: holding several decisions side by side, testing a distinction across all of them at once, and finding the passage you half-remember.
Then you go back, because a synthesis built from a frozen set of documents cannot tell you whether the law moved.
The habit worth leaving with is knowing which question you are asking, and therefore which tool you should be in.